Fabric Thermal Comfort Index
Thermal Comfort Index of Fabrics
Thermal Comfort Index — 30 textiles, 4 axes, 1 interactive tool
The Misciano Thermal Comfort Index is an editorial estimate, not a laboratory study, and refers to three internationally recognised testing standards that together capture the full spectrum of fabric thermal behaviour. ISO 11092 (sweating guarded hotplate method) provides the primary measurement of thermal resistance (Rct) and evaporative resistance (Ret), quantifying how effectively a fabric insulates against heat loss and how readily it allows moisture vapour to escape. This dual measurement is essential because a fabric that traps heat efficiently but blocks perspiration will feel uncomfortably clammy, while one that breathes freely but offers no insulation will leave the wearer cold. ASTM D737 (Frazier air permeability test) complements ISO 11092 by measuring the volume of air that passes through a fabric per unit area per unit time, expressed in cm³/cm²/s, providing a direct indication of ventilation capacity. Together, these three parameters — thermal resistance, evaporative resistance and air permeability — form the reference framework behind our editorial thermal comfort estimates, ensuring that no single aspect of thermal performance is overweighted at the expense of overall wearability.
Each standard is widely adopted by accredited testing laboratories worldwide, and its method is publicly documented. No equipment was operated by Misciano for this index. ISO 139 prescribes the standard atmospheric conditions used for textile testing.
The CLO (clothing insulation) unit is the cornerstone of our thermal comfort index, defined as the thermal resistance required to maintain a sedentary person comfortable at 21°C with 50% relative humidity and 0.1 m/s air velocity. One CLO equals 0.155 m²K/W of thermal resistance, a value originally derived from a typical men’s business suit in the 1940s. The reference method for CLO is the sweating guarded hotplate (SGHP) per ISO 11092, in which a heated plate maintained at 35°C (simulating skin temperature) is covered with the test fabric, and the power required to maintain constant temperature is precisely recorded. The thermal resistance Rct is calculated from the temperature differential, heating power and exposed area, then converted to CLO units by dividing by 0.155.
Reported CLO values are editorial estimates: Misciano has not tested these fabrics, so no measurement uncertainty applies. Values below 0.5 CLO indicate lightweight summer fabrics suitable for temperatures above 25°C, while values above 1.5 CLO correspond to heavy winter fabrics appropriate for sub-zero conditions when layered. The conversion formula Rct (m²K/W) = CLO × 0.155 allows direct comparison with engineering thermal conductivity data, bridging the gap between textile science and building physics literature.
Breathability in our index is an editorial estimate drawing on three reference methods. Air permeability is typically measured using the Frazier method (ASTM D737) at a pressure differential of 125 Pa across a 38.3 cm² test area, with results expressed in cm³/cm²/s. High values (above 100 cm³/cm²/s for gauze-weight fabrics) indicate excellent ventilation, while values below 1 cm³/cm²/s (typical of tightly woven rainwear) suggest minimal air exchange. Moisture vapour transmission rate (MVTR) is typically measured per ASTM E96 (upright cup method, Procedure B), quantifying the grams of water vapour transmitted through 1 m² of fabric in 24 hours. Active fabrics require an MVTR above 5,000 g/m²/24h to prevent the sensation of clamminess during moderate exercise, while premium breathable membranes like Gore-Tex achieve 15,000-25,000 g/m²/24h.
Drying time completes our breathability triad, and the reference protocol measures it by weighing a fabric sample before and after controlled wetting (0.2 ml distilled water per cm²), then monitoring mass at 5-minute intervals under standard conditions (20°C, 65% RH, 0.1 m/s air flow) until the sample returns to within 1% of its dry weight. Indicative literature figures, not Misciano measurements: synthetic polyester typically dries in 30-45 minutes under these conditions, merino wool in 90-120 minutes and cotton in 120-180 minutes. The composite breathability score in our editorial estimates weighs air permeability at 35%, MVTR at 40% and drying time at 25%, reflecting the relative importance of each factor for all-day comfort in varying activity levels.
Moisture management can be described using the AATCC 195 Liquid Moisture Management Properties test, which provides a comprehensive fingerprint of how a fabric handles liquid perspiration. The SDL Atlas Moisture Management Tester (MMT) applies a controlled volume of synthetic perspiration solution (0.9% NaCl) to the fabric’s inner surface (skin side) and simultaneously measures moisture transport through electrical resistance sensors on both faces of the fabric. The test yields five key metrics: wetting time (seconds for initial absorption on the top and bottom surfaces), absorption rate (% per second), maximum wetted radius on both faces (mm), spreading speed (mm/s) and one-way transport capacity (the difference in moisture content between the two faces, indicating directional wicking efficiency).
From these five metrics, the AATCC 195 protocol calculates an Overall Moisture Management Capability (OMMC) index ranging from 0 to 1, where values above 0.6 classify a fabric as “moisture management fabric” and values above 0.8 as “fast-absorbing and quick-drying fabric.” Indicative literature ranges, not Misciano measurements, put merino wool at OMMC values of 0.55-0.65, polyester athletic knits at 0.70-0.85, and untreated cotton at 0.30-0.40 due to its slow drying despite good initial absorption. Our editorial estimates weight the OMMC score at 20% of the overall thermal comfort rating, recognising that even a fabric with excellent thermal resistance and air permeability will feel uncomfortable if it cannot efficiently manage perspiration moisture during normal wear.
Our index covers 30 fabric types, described from public technical documentation; Misciano has not procured or tested these samples. Typical specifications include: Mongolian Grade A cashmere (14.5μm, 280 g/m²), Mulberry silk charmeuse 6A (19 momme), Italian virgin wool gabardine (Super 120s, 260 g/m²), French linen plain weave (180 g/m²), Egyptian Giza 87 cotton poplin (120 g/m²), Tencel/Lyocell twill (200 g/m²) and various blends. The remaining fabric types are general references drawn from the same public documentation.
No fabric was conditioned or tested by Misciano; ISO 139 sets the standard conditions used for textile testing. Scores are editorial estimates for commercially finished fabrics, aiming at real-world comfort rather than raw fibre performance. No specimens were cut or tested by Misciano, so there is no laboratory campaign to report.
The temperature suitability ranges displayed in our index are editorial estimates based on CLO values and general wear guidance, not validated by manikin or volunteer tests. No manikin trials were run for this index.
No volunteer panel was run for this index.
The scores and temperature ranges are editorial estimates by the Misciano editorial team, based on public technical documentation. No external expert panel reviewed or validated them.
The weighting formula (thermal resistance 40%, breathability 25%, moisture management 20%, air permeability 15%) is an editorial choice by the Misciano team, not endorsed by any external panel.
Methodology and Scientific References
Testing Standards
CLO Measurement Protocol
Breathability Testing
Moisture Management Testing
Fabric Selection and Editorial Estimates
Temperature Range Calibration
Editorial Review
For Journalists and Bloggers
Cite this index in your articles. Scores are Misciano editorial estimates, not laboratory results; please attribute them as such.
Key Figures
Citation Formats
Method and sources
The ratings, scores and rankings on this page are an editorial estimate by the Misciano editorial team. They are based on public technical documentation (standards, material data sheets, specialist literature). They do not come from laboratory tests carried out by or for Misciano.
Standardised test methods these criteria refer to (public standards, available on iso.org):
- ISO 12947-2:2016 : abrasion resistance (Martindale method)
- ISO 12945-2:2020 : pilling (modified Martindale method)
- ISO 105-C06:2010 : colour fastness to washing
- ISO 105-B02:2014 : colour fastness to light
- ISO 13934-1:2013 : tensile properties of fabrics
- ISO 11092:2026 : thermal and water-vapour resistance (thermal comfort)
- ISO 9237:1995 : air permeability (breathability)
- ISO 3801:1977 : mass per unit area of woven fabrics
- ISO 1833-1:2020 : quantitative analysis of fibre blends
- ISO 2076:2021 : generic names of man-made fibres
